You Can't Have Thanksgiving Without the Hard

I have this discussion with my family and friends about the holiday getting lost in the shadows, called Thanksgiving. Now, full disclosure, I love Christmas. I love putting up the tree, the lights, and the decorations. I love that there is an entire genre of music for the Christmas season. Those who know me know I love Christmastime.

But I love Thanksgiving also. The conversation I keep having is how Thanksgiving gets no respect these days. November 1st rolls around and the Christmas decorations are up. Starbucks introduces their holiday cups and new seasonal drinks, of which I am a huge fan. All the stores put their Christmas goods out for sale. And I love it.

However, there is this holiday we have called Thanksgiving. It's important for us, not just because it's good for us to be thankful. Thanksgiving represents struggle. You give thanks because you made it through the hard season. You remember the difficulties and then you pause, eat, and express thanks for still being here.

Here is what keeps striking me this year. You cannot have Thanksgiving if you haven't gone through the hard.

The first Thanksgiving was a survivor's meal

We teach it to our kids with construction paper hats and a friendly feast, so it is easy to forget what actually took place. The people at that table had just come through the worst year of their lives.

Of the one hundred and two who came over on the Mayflower, about half were dead by the spring. Forty five people. At the worst of that winter they were burying two or three a day in a frozen field, and the ground was so hard they struggled to dig it. By the fall of 1621, the table was smaller than the guest list they had planned.

The Wampanoag who joined them knew grief too. Sickness had swept the villages along that coast a few years earlier, and they had buried their own. So when about ninety of them sat down with fifty settlers for three days of eating, it was not a celebration of abundance. It was a meal of survivors. There was venison and wild fowl and corn. There was no pumpkin pie and there were no forks. But there was something better. There was memory. They knew exactly what they had come through.

Two years later the pattern showed up even more plainly. In the spring of 1623 the rains stopped. The crops dried up, and the colony faced another winter of want. Governor Bradford called for a day of fasting and prayer. They humbled themselves and asked God to send rain. Before that day was over, the rain came, and it kept coming for two weeks. So the colony set aside a day for thanksgiving.

Read that again. They fasted first. Then they feasted. That is the shape of the holiday.

It is not an American invention, by the way. God built it into the life of Israel. Look at what He told them to say when they brought the thanksgiving offering.

Deuteronomy 26:5-9 (NLT)

“My father was a wandering Aramean, and he went down into Egypt with a few people. But the Egyptians mistreated us and made us suffer. Then we cried out to the Lord, the God of our fathers, and the Lord heard our voice. So the Lord brought us out of Egypt with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm.”

They could not give thanks without first telling the story of the slavery. The hard part was required. Then came the feast and the rejoicing.

Have you ever tried to give thanks without naming what you came through? It comes out hollow, doesn't it. We tend to make things up for which we are thankful. Something is missing and we know it.

The nation kept the same pattern

George Washington's first national proclamation of thanksgiving, in 1789, was not a mood. It was an assignment. He asked the country to set aside a day to acknowledge God's providence with grateful hearts.

Abraham Lincoln gave us the holiday we actually keep. He proclaimed it in October of 1863, and his own words were that it came "in the midst of a civil war of unequaled magnitude and severity." Think about that for a second. He did not wait for the war to end before calling the nation to thanks. He called it to give thanks in the middle of the hardest season in its history, and he asked God to forgive the nation's own offenses in the same breath.

Then in 1939, President Roosevelt moved the date up a week to give merchants more shopping days before Christmas. People were furious. They called it Franksgiving. Congress stepped in two years later and fixed it permanently on the fourth Thursday. So the one time we nearly lost this holiday, we nearly lost it to a sale. Ironic…don't ya think?

We are a people who will move a day of gratitude to get a week of margin on retail.

The valley is where thanksgiving is born

Here is what I have learned in twenty five years of walking with leaders, and in fifty five years of walking with myself. We do not give thanks on the mountain by looking at the view. We give thanks on the mountain by remembering the valley, the struggle, the enormous effort it took to get on top to see the view.

When you are in the valley, you fast, you pray, and you ask God to deliver you. I often call it "The Valley of Suck." When He does, you have a day of thanksgiving and celebration. That rhythm is all through Scripture.

Psalm 107 tells it four different ways. Wanderers in the desert (Psalm 107:4-9). Prisoners in chains (107:10-16). Fools who suffered for their own rebellion (107:17-22). Sailors caught in a storm so violent it melted their courage (107:23-32).

Psalm 107:6, 8 (NLT)

“Then they cried out to the Lord in their trouble, and he delivered them from their distress. Let them give thanks to the Lord for his unfailing love.”

They cried out. He delivered. They gave thanks. That is the order.

Hannah wept in the temple because she could not have a child (1 Samuel 1:10-11). God answered, and she prayed, "My heart rejoices in the Lord" (1 Samuel 2:1, NLT). Jehoshaphat stood in front of an army he could not beat, called a fast for the whole nation (2 Chronicles 20:3-4), and then sent the choir out in front of the troops (2 Chronicles 20:21). Jonah, from inside the fish, said, "With shouts of grateful praise I will sacrifice to you" (Jonah 2:9, NLT).

And Jesus. On the night He was handed over, knowing exactly what was coming, He took the bread and gave thanks (1 Corinthians 11:23-24). If anyone had a right to skip the gratitude that night, it was Him.

Then there were ten lepers (Luke 17:11-19). Ten healed men, walking miracles. Only one came back. Only one turned around and threw himself at Jesus' feet and thanked Him. And he was the foreigner, the outsider, the one with no reason to be included.

Nine others got their healing. One came back to give thanks. He remembered the struggle. He knew the years in the valley. He was thankful.

What we lose when we skip the hard

Our consumer world has trained us to move on. The sale starts at midnight. The next thing is already in the cart. And here is the cost. We do not pause on the hard, so we do not give thanks in light of the hard, so we eventually lose the memory of where we came from. Don't skip over the hard of your life this year. Remember it and give thanks.

Deuteronomy 8:2 (NLT)

“Remember how the Lord your God led you all the way in the wilderness these forty years, to humble you and to test you in order to know what was in your heart.”

The wilderness was not an accident on the way to the promise. It was part of the curriculum. It was so hard. Men and women who do not remember the wilderness cannot know what is in their heart.

Thanksgiving is the one holiday about what you already have. We give thanks for today. For being alive, still breathing, and making it.

What I am doing this year

I want to challenge you and encourage you, so here is what I am putting into my own practice.

I am going to name the hard thing out loud. Around the table I am going to ask a question. What did we survive this year? Not what did we accomplish. What did we come through. There is a reason God told His people to build piles of stones at the places where He rescued them (Joshua 4:1-7). So the children would ask what the stones meant, and the answer would be a story about a hard season and a good God. Build the pile.

I am going to give thanks before I feel it. Psalm 116 calls it a sacrifice of thanksgiving (Psalm 116:17), and sometimes it costs something. Some years the truth is that you are still in the valley on the fourth Thursday. The psalmists knew that. One psalm ends in darkness and stays there (Psalm 88). You can offer thanks in the dark without pretending the dark is light. That is not hypocrisy. That is faith. That is looking toward hope.

I am going to be thankful and celebrate the good. I'm so grateful for the journey and adventure God has me on. I'm thankful for my family, friends, community, and the opportunity to invest into the lives of people. I'm so grateful for my new granddaughter. Take time to list out who and what you are thankful for.

We do not want to forget

Thanksgiving may get very little respect because gratitude only means something if you are willing to remember the hard. Remembering is slow and it is painful, so we skip it and move on to the next thing.

But you cannot have Thanksgiving without the hard. The first ones gave thanks because they were still here. So can we. So should we. Name the valley. Name the deliverance. Celebrate. Then eat.

I believe that your best days are before you…not behind you. We all need a little encouragement, wisdom, and help from time to time. We can't accomplish our goals in isolation or always on our own. We need each other. Remember, you are not alone. Remember the hard. It's time to thrive. Let's do it together. Happy Thanksgiving!

Rick

Next
Next

the harvest is plenty